Sullivan County Prosecutor

Most Wanted – Criminal Division

Most Wanted Individuals

This page contains a partial list of individuals who are wanted on Criminal Warrants out of Sullivan County. 

If you know the whereabouts of any of these individuals, contact the Sullivan County Prosecutor’s office or any other law enforcement agency immediately.  Do NOT try to apprehend any of these individuals yourself!

Under Indiana law, all defendants are presumed innocent until proven guilty in a court of law.”

Allen, Latonia

No Photo Available

No Photo Available


Name:  Latonia Allen

Date of Birth:  12/12/87

Accused of:  Conspiracy to Commit Trafficking  with Inmate, C Felony

Last Known Address:  Indianapolis, IN


Arterberry, Nicole

Arterberry, Nicole

Name:  Nicole L. Arterberry

Date of Birth:

Accused of:  Petition to Revoke Probation under the original charge of Receiving Stolen Property, D Felony

Last Known Address:  Evansville, IN


Helton, Garrett

Garrett Helton

Garrett Helton


Name:  Garrett L. Helton

Date of Birth:

Accused of:  Petition to Revoke Probation under the original charge of Possession of Methamphetamine, D Felony

Last Known Address:  Farmersburg, IN


Jackson, Cynthia

Cynthia Jackson

Name:  Cynthia L. Jackson

Date of Birth:  9/13/62

Accused of:  Violation of Terms of Probation, Failure to Report for Drug Screen

Last Known Address:  Hymera, IN

Rohlfing, Matthew

Matthew Rohlfing

Matthew Rohlfing


Name: Matthew Rohlfing

Date of Birth:  2/15/76

Accused Of:  Failure to Appear on Charge of Nonsupport of a Dependent Child, Class D Felony

Last Known Address:  Hayward, WI


Williams, Tony

Williams, Tony

Name:  Tony T. Williams

Date of Birth:

Accused of:  Failure to abide by the Court’s order while on bond

Last Known Address:  Sullivan, IN